Eco-Friendly Mission
Every pie supports ocean conservation. Taste the difference while making an impact.
Available To Ship!
-
Original price $69.00 - Original price $69.00Original price$69.00$69.00 - $69.00Current price $69.00Whole Key Lime Pie (9") (SHIP TO ME!)
Coastal Key Lime PieOur Coastal Key Lime Pie recipe provides the perfect balance between tart and creaminess, with a signature, buttery, graham cracker coconut crust t...
View full detailsOriginal price $69.00 - Original price $69.00Original price$69.00$69.00 - $69.00Current price $69.00 -
Original price $72.00 - Original price $72.00Original price$72.00$72.00 - $72.00Current price $72.00Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie (4 Pops) (SHIP TO ME!)
Coastal Key Lime PieTake your key lime pie experience to the next level! Try our Coastal Key Lime Pie dipped in decadent dark chocolate, served on a stick for easy en...
View full detailsOriginal price $72.00 - Original price $72.00Original price$72.00$72.00 - $72.00Current price $72.00 -
Original price $76.00 - Original price $76.00Original price$76.00$76.00 - $76.00Current price $76.00Mini Key Lime Pie (5") (4 Pies) (SHIP TO ME!)
Coastal Key Lime Pie"Mini me, you complete me!" Experience our Coastal Key Lime Pie in a mini 5" tart - perfect for one (or two if you're willing to share!). Our Coa...
View full detailsOriginal price $76.00 - Original price $76.00Original price$76.00$76.00 - $76.00Current price $76.00 -
Original price $88.00 - Original price $88.00Original price$88.00$88.00 - $88.00Current price $88.00GLUTEN FREE Mini Key Lime Pie (4 Mini Pies) (SHIP TO ME!)
Coastal Key Lime PieOur GLUTEN FREE Coastal Key Lime Pie recipe provides the perfect balance between tart and creaminess, with a buttery, graham cracker coconut crust ...
View full detailsOriginal price $88.00 - Original price $88.00Original price$88.00$88.00 - $88.00Current price $88.00 -
View all Ship To Me!
A Taste of the Coast
A Slice of Coastal Bliss
Crafted with care, our Key Lime Pies are more than just dessert—they're a taste of the beach, a moment of joy, and a reminder to savor the simple things. From our family kitchen to your table, every pie tells a story of love, tradition, and dedication to quality.
Why Coastal Key Lime Pie?
Testimonials
"From the very first bite, it was evident that
this pie was something extraordinary. The texture was
velvety and smooth with just the right amount of creaminess. It was sheer perfection...a culinary
masterpiece!
Greg Shotzberger
"Absolutely delicious! One of the best we've had! Whole family loved it!"
Diana Palomba-Cooper
"Absolutely the BEST key lime pie out there!"
Greg Meleney
"Some of the best key lime pie I’ve ever had!!!"
Matthew Weitzman
"Recently had Coastal Key Lime Pie for the first time and both my wife and I LOVED them! Perfectly balanced key lime pie! Not too sweet, not too tart... just perfect!"
Scott Shelley
"This pie was better than the Key Lime pie I had in Key West. The owners are knowledgeable and very kind."
Pat McKenna
"ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!! I was hesitant about their Gluten Free…they blew it out the park!!!!!! Highly recommend to everyone!!!"
Josh McKinney
"As Key Lime Pies go, Coastal is AUTHENTICALLY the BEST ever! Flavorful, Creamy, Fresh. And that Crust! ...or shall I say "buttery, cookie crust," an Outstanding compliment to that Wonderful Filling!"
Susan Slw
