Skip to content
Questions? Call/Text: (302) 727-8868 Email: hello@coastalkeylimepie.com
Questions? Call/Text: (302) 727-8868 Email: hello@coastalkeylimepie.com

Ship To Me!

We can ship our handmade Key Lime Pies right to your door!  Overnight (1-day) shipping must be selected at checkout to complete your order.  Orders received by 8:00 AM EST will be available to ship same day.  We ship on the following days of the week:

  • Monday (for delivery on Tuesday)
  • Tuesday (for delivery on Wednesday)
  • Wednesday (for delivery on Thursday)
  • Thursday (for delivery on Friday)

Product pricing below includes:

  • One-day UPS ground shipping to DE, NJ, MD, and DC (additional shipping fees will be added for deliveries to all other states for Next Day Air shipping costs)
  • Dry ice to keep your pie frozen in transit
  • Eco-friendly insulated packaging

Filters

$
$
  • Original price $69.00 - Original price $69.00
    Original price
    $69.00
    $69.00 - $69.00
    Current price $69.00

    Whole Key Lime Pie (9") (SHIP TO ME!)

    Coastal Key Lime Pie

    The Ultimate Key Lime Pie – Handmade Perfection in Every Bite! Indulge in the perfect harmony of tangy and sweet with our handmade-from-scratch Key...

    View full details
    Original price $69.00 - Original price $69.00
    Original price
    $69.00
    $69.00 - $69.00
    Current price $69.00
  • Original price $72.00 - Original price $72.00
    Original price
    $72.00
    $72.00 - $72.00
    Current price $72.00

    Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie (4 Pops) (SHIP TO ME!)

    Coastal Key Lime Pie

    Chocolate-Dipped Key Lime Pie Pop – A Tropical Indulgence with a Chocolatey Twist! Experience the ultimate dessert fusion with our handmade Chocola...

    View full details
    Original price $72.00 - Original price $72.00
    Original price
    $72.00
    $72.00 - $72.00
    Current price $72.00
  • Original price $76.00 - Original price $76.00
    Original price
    $76.00
    $76.00 - $76.00
    Current price $76.00

    Mini Key Lime Pie (5") (4 Pies) (SHIP TO ME!)

    Coastal Key Lime Pie

    Mini Key Lime Pie 4-Pack – A Bite-Sized Vacation in Every Bite! Escape to paradise with our handmade Mini Key Lime Pie 4-Pack—the perfect way to in...

    View full details
    Original price $76.00 - Original price $76.00
    Original price
    $76.00
    $76.00 - $76.00
    Current price $76.00
  • Original price $88.00 - Original price $88.00
    Original price
    $88.00
    $88.00 - $88.00
    Current price $88.00

    GLUTEN FREE Mini Key Lime Pie (4 Mini Pies) (SHIP TO ME!)

    Coastal Key Lime Pie

    Gluten-Free Mini Key Lime Pie 4-Pack – Indulgence Without Limits! Satisfy your cravings with our handmade, gluten-free Mini Key Lime Pie—crafted fo...

    View full details
    Original price $88.00 - Original price $88.00
    Original price
    $88.00
    $88.00 - $88.00
    Current price $88.00
  • Original price $82.00 - Original price $82.00
    Original price
    $82.00
    $82.00 - $82.00
    Current price $82.00

    Mini Key Lime Pie (5") Variety Pack (Gluten & Gluten Free) (4 Pies) (SHIP TO ME!)

    Coastal Key Lime Pie

    Variety is the spice of life!  Satisfy your gluten loving AND gluten free key lime pie fans with this 4-pack of mini key lime pies.  Package includ...

    View full details
    Original price $82.00 - Original price $82.00
    Original price
    $82.00
    $82.00 - $82.00
    Current price $82.00